laperlisha Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - EXCELENTE!!!!!

laperlisha Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - Me gusta màs esta versión que la de Beyonce

NoleChik Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - love it! :o) but seriously...Christina sings it big cuz she knows she has a big voice and she uses it like crazy, but its a beautiful voice so its ok :o) and Beyonce sings it beautifully too...but nothings better than the original...relax people just enjoy it and if u dont like it then find Etta James' version and be happy! :oD I still love Christina tho...u go girl! ;o]

shabas604 Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - She oversung it, still pretty good though

shipp715 Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - beyonce was way better

BeautifullyCreated07 Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - Christina has a great voice but she definitely oversang this song. I will say, the rifts starting around 2mins were impressive.

oceanuneedme Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - lol you didnt just dont want this to go on any longer than it has to

oceanuneedme Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - i meant no you didnt seem rude...not the spelling.......sorry

scavo2003 Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - Waaay better!!! Beyonce was much more subtle / silky smooth in her expression. Christina overscreamed it like she normally does. Ooooh and Aaah doesn't a song make.

olexia07 Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - I love her voice but I honestly like Beyonce's better I really don't like when she oversings the song.

cocodivatime Says:

Dec 3, 2008 - Umm no that was too much. She over did it and I was annoyed the whole time.

grabuschka Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - guys! beyoncé's and christina are different...christina's is for me a right blues voice...etta james screamed a lot too...its the blues guys its the blues...christina's voice remains incredible and unique!!! so let her oversing and make ooohh and ahhh..because SHE CAN!! but well its always an endless discussion...taste of music you cannot "comment" away..

pulze28 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - she did not screamed but it was kinda too much. but since its the blues then itsok, better than bees.

shelana2008 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - how can you people say beyonce did this better..my god listen to the notez christinas did on this song..she killed it!!!

melani411 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - i just think they all sound good all 3 have their own style

stilltheBADDEST Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - beyonce can't fuck wit christina! SHE IS A VET BABY!

Tbe2007 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - She sings good but she destroyed the meaning of this song the way she sung it. Etta´s and Bey´s versions have more meaning to it.

xxCullensforever0306 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - if anything she hits the notes perfectly yes it was a lil much but she does the song great. Altho etta was great too. but Christina did it justice.

aslanbas1 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - Dam!!!!!! little girl worked out.

ChocolatSunshine Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - All three of them did a better than I ever could. : ) Get 'em girls!!

delumbre05 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - great performance!!!!

hotspot147 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - now dont go talking crazy take ya pills and have a seat christina is my girl and all but she aint got shit on bey act like u know AHA!

Hofffan87 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - All the stans here saying Beyonce's better, her version is straight out of American Idol. This version is a mile higher than what Idol can handle. This is diva status, Beyonce was straight weak.

Hofffan87 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - Fayme20 and datdude717, both of you go listen to Christina's version of I Love You Porgy. The girl can just 'sing' if she wanted to. She just riffs because she can. She does alot of stuff because she can. All the divas riff and scream because they can.

Fayme20 Says:

Dec 4, 2008 - Oh of course Hofffan. If I thought that about Christina I would not have said that she has a good voice. I know that she can just 'sing' from her earlier hits (Genie in a Bottle, What a Girl Wants) but, in my opinion, when she's live she tends to over-riff and do 'vocal acrobats' as if she NEEDS to in order to gain praise. Yes divas riff and scream (on their own songs) yet they know when to stop. Especially in a ballad like this one. Plus this wasn't her song to over-do.