aloofbooks Says:
May 11, 2008 - One of my favorite Madonna songs!
bluepanther555 Says:
May 26, 2008 - BEAUTIFUL
sgsfguy Says:
May 27, 2008 - Still one of the most beautiful videos ever shot. It holds up after all of these years.
dayg715 Says:
Jun 1, 2008 - video is amazing, but the song blows.
yu2be07 Says:
Jun 1, 2008 - Thank you so much for posting this video! SO POWERFUL. I remember this as a teen. Even then there was something about it that gripped my heart. Now seeing and hearing it again after all these years, I fully understand the message and why I was affected so deeply by it. Thank you.
yu2be07 Says:
Jun 1, 2008 - I know... I do the same.
yu2be07 Says:
Jun 1, 2008 - Really? I did not know that!
StubberRubber Says:
Jun 14, 2008 - They should do a rap cover of this!
FrFrank43 Says:
Jun 26, 2008 - To amazing to even comment on this video. Children live like this on a daily basis. Wanting their acceptance by thier Parents and never get it. No wonder there is so much damage in adult relationships that need repairing .Madonna has always has insight and has a gift beyond the singing and performing. How can anyone hurt an innocent child????
OCrebel Says:
Jul 14, 2008 - this video is a masterpeice. I wish Madonna did videos like this still.
easyLiving777 Says:
Jul 19, 2008 - great song!
dirtyhyna13 Says:
Aug 1, 2008 - i remember what happend 2 me when i was teenager, pretty sad... but this is a wonderful song!!!! jizzum
thenewgirlawakens Says:
Aug 19, 2008 - My dad's been dead for years...and I still cannot find the way to forgive him...
ThePaperBoy21858 Says:
Aug 27, 2008 - talk to him about it.
thenewgirlawakens Says:
Aug 27, 2008 - He killed himself.. I am glad he did in a way...
ThePaperBoy21858 Says:
Aug 27, 2008 - well i know hes dead, but u can still talk to him...and make things right, do it now before ur gone too!
brandonkirk Says:
Sep 11, 2008 - People who have been hurt, tend to hurt others. It's like the video on here says, someone really hurt your dad in his life. Unfortunately, when we hurt we sometimes hurt the ones we love. Just because your dad hurt you it doesn't mean that he didn't love you. You don't have to justify what he did, forgive the man that he probably wanted to be, even though he wasn't strong enough to be.
Patriotic13 Says:
Sep 22, 2008 - i agree this is one of my favorites ever watch bad girl
femalepeachycat Says:
Sep 30, 2008 - I love this song. it has so much meaning thank you for posting this. I was emotionally abused as a child and this song has so much meaning to me.
mikerobert27 Says:
Oct 23, 2008 - This song has much import, the hard lessons we learn, the lessons we fogot, and the lessons we wish we could relive. Oh father, the lessons of life, how you taught them so well and at the same so badly...this video reminds me of the lessons, even though I'm a male and twenty eight years of age, I still cry when I hear this. To all those of you who survived, I love you all. Be strong, find that power in yourself to get through and at the end you will finally understand.
shieldsnatalie Says:
Nov 22, 2008 - is this song about madonna's father? and how she was treated by him after her mother's death?
stakado17 Says:
Nov 22, 2008 - I LOVE THIS VIDEO
Igo4God Says:
Nov 24, 2008 - I can relate to this video. My father abused me physically and emotionally..The scares never go away they are always there but he can no longer hurt me.
deltalady72 Says:
Dec 1, 2008 - thank you madonna i was raised in an abused home with my step mom and birth dad. Joan crawford was a vacation i now have two step daughters and i know i can do better than that.
Stiggy333 Says:
May 8, 2008 - Such an incredible video. Always been one of my favorites. Beautiful.